Congratulations to the ten former Indiana high school players that earned NAIA All-America Honors.
| Name | College | High School | Honor |
| Skyler Van Note | Marian (IN) | Wapahani HS | First Team |
| Ryan Czerniak | Taylor IN | Covenant Christian HS | First Team |
| McKenzie Powell | Indiana University South Bend | New Prairie HS | Third Team |
| Reece Shirley | IU East IN | Michigan City HS | Third Team |
| Lexi Broyles | IU Kokomo IN | Kankakee Valley HS | Third Team |
| Kacy Bragg | Taylor IN | Warsaw HS | Third Team |
| Isabelle North-Greene | Bethel (IN) | Homeschool | Honorable Mention |
| Maddy Payne | Bethel (IN) | NorthWood HS | Honorable Mention |
| Jessica Swimm | Indiana University East | Hagerstown HS | Honorable Mention |
| Jai-lyn Norwood | Marian IN | Lawrence Central HS | Honorable Mention |