| Player’s Name | School | Class | Year | Team |
| Anna Ballengee | Barr-Reeve High School | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Amiya Jones | Chales A. Tindley High School | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Addie Kittle | Clay City High School | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Corrissa Remter | Covington High School | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Morgan Roberts | Cowan High School | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Lindsey Ingenito | Daleville High School | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Sarah Tedder | Hauser High School | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Sydney Schoen | Hauser High School | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Erin Pasch | Indianapolis Lutheran High School | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Gretchen Kuckkan | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Jozee Evans | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Sami Royer | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Julianne Bell | Loogootee High School | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Haley Gleitz | Pioneer High School | 1A | 2017 | First Team |
| Hannah Graber | Barr-Reeve High School | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Kara Hughes | Barr-Reeve High School | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Kara Hughes | Barr-Reeve High School | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Avalee Jeffers | Clay City High School | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Becky Schoen | Hauer High School | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Dara Milivojac | Indianapolis Lutheran High School | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Kristen Simons | Indianapolis Lutheran High School | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Allison Tharp | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Kacey Brickley | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Calli Wininger | Loogootee High School | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Adison Denu | Northeast DuBois High School | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Clare Mangin | Northeast DuBois High School | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Caitlyn Reynolds | Springs Valley High School | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Breanna Metger | Tecumseh High School | 1A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Chloe Holder | Tecumseh High School | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Megan Miller | Alexandria-Monroe High School | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Jenna Dal Santo | Andrean High School | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Serena Wagner | Andrean High School | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Christina Dal Santo | Andrean High School | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Ally Barkhaus | Blackhawk Christian Academy | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Megan Herr | Carroll (Flora) High School | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Alli Stumler | Christian Academy of Indiana | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Nichole Collins | Christian Academy of Indiana | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Julia Lostutler | Christian Academy of Indiana | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Alison Ford | Covenant Christian High School | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Rachel Newport | Covenant Christian High School | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Hope Notter | Covenant Christian High School | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Madison Candler | Heritage Christian High School | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Sloan Stewart | Madison Grant High School | 2A | 2017 | First Team |
| Blaine Kelly | Alexandria-Monroe High School | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Mary Sayre | Alexandria-Monroe High School | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Julie Negy | Blackhawk Christian Academy | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Lexi Lester | Christian Academy of Indiana | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Ryan Czerniak | Covenant Christian High School | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Rachel Phillips | Heritage Christian High School | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Sarah Bohman | North Decatur High School | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Adria Hartley | North Miami High School | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Caitlyn Bolser | North Miami High School | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Lily Sumner | Park Tudor High School | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Grace Pfieffer | Rochester High School | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Madelyn Sailors | Rochester High School | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Molly Griffin | Scecina Memorial High School | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Hallie Holbrook | Shenandoah High School | 2A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Elena Redmond | Bishop Chatard High School | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Reagan Hopp | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Taila Trabue | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Brooklyn Snodgrass | Brownstown Central High School | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Molly Hunt | Delta High School | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Brooke Smith | Leo High School | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Isabella Ravotto | Mishawaka Marian High School | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Cecily Jester | New Castle High School | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Mabrey Shaffmaster | New Castle High School | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Melani Shaffmaster | New Castle High School | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Kiersten Cooper | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Eden Dolezal | South Bend St. Joseph High School | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Havyn Gates | Wapahani High School | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Skylar VanNote | Wapahani High School | 3A | 2017 | First Team |
| Tori Miller | Bellmont High School | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Anna Wuench | Bishop Chatard High School | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Abbey Richman | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Davia Poytress | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Abby Wahl | Heritage Hills High School | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Makayla Knoblauch | Leo High School | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Kassady Chadzucki | Mishawaka Marian High School | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Kelsey Ketcham | Mishawaka Marian High School | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Bailey Cox | New Castle High School | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Jenny Lundy | Northview High School | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Macie Garrison | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Zoie Zimmerman | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Estella Davis | Wapahani High School | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Lexi Spence | Wapahani High School | 3A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Darian Goins | Avon High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| Holly Estridge | Avon High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| Jael Johnson | Avon High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| MJ Hammill | Center Grove High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| Alex Equihua | Crown Point High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| Morgan Chadon | Crown Point High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| Reece Kral | Crown Point High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| Lauren Matthews | Lawrence North High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| Catie Baird | Perry Meridian High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| Courtney Glotzbach | Providence High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| Marissa Hornung | Providence High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| Kylie Murr | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| Makenzie Knuckles | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| Katie Isenbarger | Zionsville High School | 4A | 2017 | First Team |
| Ellen LeMasters | Center Grove High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Peyton Yelich | Crown Point High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Mallory Hernandez | Fishers High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Mia Swearingen | Floyd Central High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Molly Ottersbach | Floyd Central High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Grace Kane | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Hannah Norveroske | Michigan City High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Allyson Cathey | New Albany High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Allison Dennemann | New Palestine High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Alli Hornung | Providence High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Hannah Irmer | Roncalli High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Emma Terwillinger | Valparaiso High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Bella Rosenthall | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Leah Daniels | Zionsville High School | 4A | 2017 | Second Team |
| Addison Ainscough | Barr-Reeve High School | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Anna Ballengee | Barr-Reeve High School | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Corrissa Remter | Covington High School | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Hannah Johnson | Hauser High School | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Rylee Morris | Indianapolis Lutheran High School | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Dara Milivojac | Indianapolis Lutheran High School | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Gretchen Kuckkan | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Jozee Evans | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Kacey Brickley | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Atlantis Clendenin | Parke Heritage High School | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Haley Gleitz | Pioneer High School | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Mikenna Landis | Pioneer High School | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Caitlyn Reynolds | Springs Valley High School | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Breanna Metzger | Tecumseh High School | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Hannah Sabotin | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2018 | First Team |
| Hannah Graber | Barr-Reeve High School | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Jasye Thompson | Barr-Reeve High School | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Alexis Huff | Cowan High School | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Gracelynn Conway | Cowan High School | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Kylie Lock | Hauser High School | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Lilly Powers | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Maddie McPerson | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Asia Crim | Loogootee High School | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Alexis Robinson | Pioneer High School | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Mackenzie Campbell | Pioneer High School | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Madison Blickenstaff | Pioneer High School | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Chloe Holder | Tecumseh High School | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Kaybree Oxley | Tecumseh High School | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Abby Schult | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Julia Lostutter | Christian Academy of Indiana | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Kendall Kerberg | Christian Academy of Indiana | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Lexi Lester | Christian Academy of Indiana | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Regan Lynn Tinkle | Hagerstown High School | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Lilly Snyder | Heritage Christian High School | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Rachel Phillips | Heritage Christian High School | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Raven Colvin | Heritage Christian High School | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Alaina Spahn | Mater Dei High School | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Kelsey Carr | Mater Dei High School | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Lauren Cox | North Judson San Pierre High School | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Makenzie Harper | North Judson San Pierre High School | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Macy Reimbold | North Judson San Pierre High School | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Lily Sumner | Park Tudor High School | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Tabatha Wagner | Wabash High School | 2A | 2018 | First Team |
| Alley Traciak | Bishop Noll High School | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Mary Markusic | Bishop Noll High School | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Rebekah Deich | Christian Academy of Indiana | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Kenzie Carter | Christian Academy of Indiana | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Alyssa Lukasik | Clinton Prairie High School | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Bailey Everett | Covenant Christian High School | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Julia Nagy | Fort Wayne Blackhawk Christian | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Jessica Lee Swimm | Hagerstown High School | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Elizabeth Phillips | Heritage Christian High School | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Payton Pokorney | Mater Dei High School | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Courtney Trusty | North Judson San Pierre High School | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Makinzi Marie Meurer | North Knox High School | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Cassidy Jean Crawford | Tipton High School | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| McKenzie Hayslett | Wabash High School | 2A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Gabriela McHugh | Angola High School | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| Anna Wuensch | Bishop Chatard High School | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| Anna Burkhardt | Bishop Dwenger High School | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| Madison Ross | Bishop Dwenger High School | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| Reagan Hopp | Brebeuf Jesuit High School | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| Brooke Smith | Leo Jr. Sr. High School | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| Isabella Ravotto | Mishawaka Marian High School | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| MyKel Simone Ivy | Muncie Burris Laboratory | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| Mabrey Shaffmaster | New Castle High School | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| Melani Shaffmaster | New Castle High School | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| Jennifer Lundy | Northview High School | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| Kambree Lucas | Northview High School | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| Kiersten Cooper | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| Madison Schermerhorn | West Noble High School | 3A | 2018 | First Team |
| Ruby Countryman | Bishop Chatard High School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Abbey Richman | Brebeuf Jesuit High School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Taila Trabue | Brebeuf Jesuit High School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Brooklyn Snodgrass | Brownstown Central High School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Keeli Darlage | Brownstown Central High School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Reagan Nuss | Brownstown Central High School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Kirsten Johnson | Danville High School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Chloe Lentych | Mishawaka Marian High School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Cailyn Bolser | Missisinewa High School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Laila Smith | New Castle High School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Caitlin Shunneson | New Castle High School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Alli Cook | Northview High School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Madison Layden | NorthwesternHigh School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Macie Garrison | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Zoie Zimmerman | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Ava Torrance | Avon High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| Abby Maesch | Avon High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| Jessica Nunge | Castle High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| Madision Hammill | Center Grove High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| Rose Duffy | Fishers High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| Brooke Humphry | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| Madison Horin | Munster High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| Lexie Almodovar | Noblesville High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| Alyssa Torres | Penn High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| Caitie Baird | Perry Meridian High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| Ali Hornung | Providence High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| Kylie Murr | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| Makenzie Knuckles | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| Tegan Seyring | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2018 | First Team |
| AleJa Culbreath | Avon High School | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Holly Eastridge | Avon High School | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Ashley Eck | Center Grove High School | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Camryn Haworth | Fishers High School | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Jenna Riley | Franklin Central High School | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Brooke Phillips | Franklin Community | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Taylor Shelton | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Carly Mills | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Emily Brown | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Lilly Bivens | Providence High School | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Hanna Mitchell | Providence High School | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Emma Halter | Roncalli High School | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Grace Hegwood | Roncalli High School | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| Mackenzie Daffinee | Westfield High School | 4A | 2018 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Elizabeth Combs | Bloomfield Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Gracelynn Rose Conway | Cowan High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Cara Cresse | F.W. Blackhawk Christian Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Asia Crim | Loogootee Jr/Sr High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Martina Demarchi | Cowan High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Jozee Evans | Lafayette Central Catholic High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Kennedy Hoffman | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Hannah Johnson | Hauser Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Dara Milivojac | Indpls. Lutheran High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Lauren O’Neill | Covington Community High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Lilly Powers | Lafayette Central Catholic High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Bailey Reynolds | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Hannah Sabotin | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Kylie VanHoy | Loogootee JrSr High School | 1A | 2019 | First Team |
| Madison Blickenstaff | Pioneer Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Grace Bond | Wes-Del Middle/Senior High School | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Sadie Brenneman | Bethany Christian School | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Kayla Brady | Lafayette Central Catholic High School | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Olivia Brooke | Pioneer Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Audrey Eurton | New Washington High School | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Jascey Harrington | Cowan High School | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Sydney Jaynes | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Jewel McCormick | Springs Valley Comm High School | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Julia Nagy | FW Blackhawk Christian Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Erin Sexauer | Central Christian Academy | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Trinity Tatlock | Southwestern Shelby High School | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Makenzie VanHoy | Loogootee JrSr High School | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Aunaka Wasil | Hauser Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2019 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Addison Ainscough | Barr Reeve High School | 2A | 2019 | First Team |
| Anna Ballengee | Barr Reeve High School | 2A | 2019 | First Team |
| Madison Beriault | Scecina High School | 2A | 2019 | First Team |
| Raven Colvin | Heritage Christian High School | 2A | 2019 | First Team |
| Chloe Cook | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2019 | First Team |
| Alexis Nelson | Southmont High School | 2A | 2019 | First Team |
| Elizabeth Phillips | Heritage Christian High School | 2A | 2019 | First Team |
| Alyvia Smith | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2019 | First Team |
| Lilly Snyder | Heritage Christian High School | 2A | 2019 | First Team |
| Mallory Summers | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2019 | First Team |
| Lily Sumner | Park Tudor High School | 2A | 2019 | First Team |
| Regan Tinkle | Hagerstown High School | 2A | 2019 | First Team |
| Lovie Wallace | Heritage Christian High School | 2A | 2019 | First Team |
| Kaitlyn Bair | Alexandria High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Atlantis Clendenin | Parke Heritage High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Hannah Graber | Barr Reeve High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Chloe Holder | Tecumseh High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Cadee Notter | Covenant Christian High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Kaybree Oxley | Tecumseh High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Katherine Sperry | Frankton High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Alison Stewart | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Jessica Swimm | Hagerstown High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Jayse Thompson | Barr Reeve High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Sidney Veatch | Southmont High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Aubrey Walton | Linton-Stockton High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Gentry Warrick | Linton Stockton High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Camryn Wise | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2019 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Helen Beach | Muncie Burris High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Taylor Brandsfield | FW Bishop Luers High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Macy Garrison | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Delaney Hogan | FW Bishop Dwenger High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Molly Hunt | Delta High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Kambree Lucas | Northview High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Kaley Lyons | FW Bishop Dwenger High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Kendra McCory | Brownstown Central High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Rachel McBride | Bellmont High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Reagan Nuss | Brownstown Central High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Riley Nuss | Brownstown Central High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Madison Payne | Northwood High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Brooke Smith | Leo High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Elise Swiskck | New Prairie High School | 3A | 2019 | First Team |
| Maggie Castleman | Heritage High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Keeli Darlage | Brownstown Central High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Eva Hudson | FW Bishop Dwenger High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Isabella Hinton | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Madison Layden | Northwestern High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Kendall Miller | Northwood High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Ashlyn Meyer | Angola High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Caroline Mullet | Northwood High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Mara Perrt | Muncie Burris High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Asia Povlin | Sullivan High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Ryan Rednour | Leo High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Maddie Siegel | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Caitlyn Snyder | Angola High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Anna Wuensch | Bishop Chatard High School | 3A | 2019 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Savana Chacon | Crown Point High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| Ashley Eck | Center Grove High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| Delaney Garner | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| Courtney Glotzbach | Providence High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| MJ Hammill | Center Grove High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| Ali Hornung | Providence High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| Brooke Humphrey | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| Carly Mills | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| Maebry Shaffmaster | New Castle High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| Melanie Shaffmaster | New Castle High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| Laila Smith | New Castle High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| Ellee Stinson | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| Kate Vinson | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| Abby Weber | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2019 | First Team |
| Lexie Almodovar | Noblesville High School | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Madison Banter | Crown Point High School | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Grace Boggess | Center Grove High School | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Emily Brown | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Victoria Bulmahn | Mt Vernon Fortville High School | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Chloe Chacoine | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Bailey Cox | New Castle Hotdog | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Emma Halter | Roncalli High School | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Rilee Jessee | Columbus East High School | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Lilian Leiner | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Abby Maesch | Avon High School | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Ceci Rush | Providence High School | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Olivia Utterback | Plainfield High School | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| Courtney Watkins | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2019 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Gracie Lowry | Bloomfield Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Gracelynn Conway | Cowan High School | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Cara Cresse | F.W. Blackhawk Christian Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Hannah Johnson | Hauser Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Dara Milivojac | Indpls. Lutheran High School | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Lilly Powers | Lafayette Central Catholic High School | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Kylie VanHoy | Loogootee JrSr High School | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Makenzie VanHoy | Loogootee JrSr High School | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Addison Baker | Northfield Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Madison Lea Blickenstaff | Pioneer Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Olivia Faith Brooke | Pioneer Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Ligia Williams | Rock Creek Community Academy | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Bailey Reynolds | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Kennedy Hoffman | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2020 | First Team |
| Sadie Brenneman | Bethany Christian School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Victoria Schopmeyer | Clay City Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Nai’a Pettit | Covington Community High School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Jascey Harrington | Cowan High School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Sophia Foster | Kouts High School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Grace Roach | Lafayette Central Catholic High School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Asia Crim | Loogootee JrSr High School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Jocelyn Strange | Loogootee JrSr High School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Kyra Kennedy | Northfield Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Hailey Elizabeth Cripe | Pioneer Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Samantha Warren | South Newton Senior High School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Kamzi Gross | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Sydney Jaynes | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Emma Sue Hepler | Triton Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2020 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Anna Ballengee | Barr Reeve High School | 2A | 2020 | First Team |
| Addison Ainscough | Barr Reeve High School | 2A | 2020 | First Team |
| Hannah Graber | Barr Reeve High School | 2A | 2020 | First Team |
| Jayse Thompson | Barr Reeve High School | 2A | 2020 | First Team |
| Madisyn Steele | Fairfield High School | 2A | 2020 | First Team |
| Raven Colvin | Heritage Christian | 2A | 2020 | First Team |
| Lilly Snyder | Heritage Christian | 2A | 2020 | First Team |
| Elizabeth Phillips | Heritage Christian | 2A | 2020 | First Team |
| Atlantis Clendenin | Parke Heritage High School | 2A | 2020 | First Team |
| Kaybree Oxley | Tecumseh High School | 2A | 2020 | First Team |
| Mariah Wyatt | Wabash High School | 2A | 2020 | First Team |
| Camryn Wise | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2020 | First Team |
| Chloe Cook | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2020 | First Team |
| Mallory Summers | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Kaitlyn Bair | Alexandria-Monroe High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Lauren Dungan | Alexandria-Monroe High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Cadee Notter | Covenant Christian High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Sophie Klieman | Evansville Mater Dei High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Kayla Miller | Fairfield High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Riley Nunn | Henryville High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Gentry Warrick | Linton-Stockton High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Sara Gomperts | Park Tudor High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Carlie Sealscott | South Adams High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Sidney Veatch | Southmont High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Lauren Brammeier | Tecumseh High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Brooklyn Schiffli | Triton Central High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Macy Bowden | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Reece Baker | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2020 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Reagan Nuss | Brownstown Central High School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Sophie Krull | Bellmont Senior High School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Eva Hudson | Bishop Dwenger High School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Naija Gadis | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Maddie Siegel | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Sydney Robinson | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Kendra McCory | Brownstown Central High School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Bailey Hartsough | Lakeland High School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Isabelle Hogan | Leo High School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Brooke Jackson | Mt. Vernon High School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Libby Steinhart | Mt. Vernon High School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Elise Swistek | New Prairie High School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Isabella Hinton | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Mallory Ramsey | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2020 | First Team |
| Bella Schumacher | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Kayla Guthrie | Brownstown Central High School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Bella Dearinger | Delta High School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| LonDynn Betts | F.W. Concordia Lutheran High School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Logan Smith | Garrett High School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Anna West | Greensburg Community High School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Payton Rolfsen | Leo High School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Abby Kesler | Muncie Burris Laboratory School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Kendal Miller | NorthWood High School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Macy Lengacher | NorthWood High School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Abby Marks | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Megan Duffy | Tri-West Senior High School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Maycee Lange | Vincennes Lincoln High School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Alaina Thorne | Washington High School | 3A | 2020 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Abby Maesch | Avon High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Camryn Haworth | Fishers High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Carly Mills | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Delaney Garner | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Chloe Chicoine | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Haley Melby | Munster High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Lourdes Torres | Munster High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Mabrey Shaffmaster | New Castle Chrysler High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Ali Hornung | Providence High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Anna Purichia | Providence High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Emma Halter | Roncalli High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Ellee Stinson | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Jaylynn Dunsmore | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Jenny Morey | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2020 | First Team |
| Kenadee Coyle | Bloomington High School South | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Bailey DeMier | Bloomington High School South | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Quinci Thomas | Brownsburg High School | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Grace Boggess | Center Grove High School | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Katie Egenolf | Center Grove High School | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Kendall Schara | Crown Point High School | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Vanessa Del Real | Crown Point High School | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Lauren Harden | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Emily Weber | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Paige Conklin | LaPorte High School | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Cecilia Bulmahn | Mt. Vernon Fortville High School | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Sarah Morton | Munster High School | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Bailey Cox | New Castle Chrysler High School | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| Laila Smith | New Castle Chrysler High Schoo | 4A | 2020 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Gracie Lowry | Bloomfield Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Emi Isom | Daleville JrSr High School | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Regan Wilson | Indpls. Lutheran High School | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Sophia Foster | Kouts MiddleHigh School | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Kaitlyn Kuckkan | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Racel Vorst | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Grace Roch | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Haley Kruse | Lakewood Park Christian School | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Jocelyn Strange | Loogootee JrSr High School | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Kylie VanHoy | Loogootee JrSr High School | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Hailey Elizabeth Cripe | Pioneer Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Ruthie Bingham | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Bailey Tabeling | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Kamzi Gross | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2021 | First Team |
| Emily Rachel Cox | Cambridge City Lincoln HS | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Amber Cruser | Covington Community | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Julia Andreassa | Daleville JrSr High School | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Allie Maire Boyer | Blackhawk Christian Academy | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Emma Segal | Frontier Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Andie Clark | Hauser Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Kassidy Boener | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Annie Haan | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Taylor Cripe | South Newton High School | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Lexi Cripe | South Newton High School | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Leigh Carnes | Springs Valley High School | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Stella Kleffman | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Kylie Antrim | Wes-Del High School | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Tori Clements | Wes-Del High School | 1A | 2021 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Angelina Majchrowicz | Andrean High School | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Marin Sanchez | Andrean High School | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Cadee Notter | Covenant Christian High School | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Sydney Stutsman | Fairfield Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Gentry Warrick | Linton-Stockton High School, | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Alexis Baney | Madison-Grant High School | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Daya Greene | Madison-Grant High School | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Julia Fullop | North Posey Sr High School | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Ava Smith | Park Tudor School | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Allison Daves | Scecina Memorial School | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Carlie Sealscott | South Adams High School | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Kaybree Oxley | Tecumseh Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Maddie Hawkins | Western Boone High School | 2A | 2021 | First Team |
| Taylor Baker | Winchester Community High School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Taylor Stinefield | Alexandria-Monroe High School | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Madison Kmetz | Andrean High School | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Danielle Newport | Covenant Christian High School | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Bella Dart | Covenant Christian High school | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Jaleigh Crawford | Elwood Community High School | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Brea Garber | Fairfield Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Holli Klettheimer | Frankton Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Gwen Dyer | Knightstown High School | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Sophia Kirschner | Park Tudor High School | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Abigail McCoy, | Scecina Memorial School | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Bailey Keusch | Southridge High School | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Julia Sanders | Triton Central High School | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Caitlyn Campbell | Winchester Community High School | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Gena Moore | Winchester Community High School | 2A | 2021 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Emma McMahon | Bellmont Senior High School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Meg Saalfrank | Bellmont Senior High School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Sydney Robinson | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Delaney Seaman | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Lola Schumacher | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Reagan Nuss | Brownstown Central High School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Kristin Bobay | F.W. Bishop Dwenger High School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Eva Hudson | F.W. Bishop Dwenger High School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Kiki Brown | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Abby Marks | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Elle Patterson | Tri-West Senior High School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Camryn Wise | Wapahani High School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Chloe Cook | Wapahani High School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Tori Kristine Woods | West Lafayette Jr/Sr High School | 3A | 2021 | First Team |
| Morgan Gaerte | Angola High School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Dylan DeCoursey | Barr Reeve Jr.-Sr. High School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Paige Busick | Bellmont Senior High School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Sienna Foster | Benton Central Jr-Sr High School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Naija Gadis | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Maddie Siegel | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Lexa Zimmerman | F.W. Bishop Dwenger High School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Londynn Betts | F.W. Concordia Lutheran High School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Morgan Ostrowski | Garrett High School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Josie Nobbe | Greensburg High School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Payton Rolfsen | Leo High School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Abby Kesler | Muncie Burris Laboratory School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Macy Lee Lengacher | NorthWood High School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Lindsay Springer | Tri-West Senior High School | 3A | 2021 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Quinci Thomas | Brownsburg High School | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Natalie Niehaus | Castle High School | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Keira Moore | Castle High School | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Gabby Dean | Columbus East High School | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Lauren Harden – | Hamilton Southeastern HS | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Chloe Chicoine | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Raegan Burns | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Cecilia Bulmahn | Mt Vernon High School | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Haley Melby | Munster High School | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Emily Hickey | Penn High School | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Macy Hatkevich | Penn High School | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Grace Purichia | Providence High School | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Emma Halter | Roncalli High School | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Emilee Hill | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2021 | First Team |
| Kendall Meller | Brownsburg High School | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Ella Bostic | Carmel High School | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Katie Egenolf | Center Grove High School | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Rachel Rossman | Crown Point High School | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Ava Vickeres | Fishers High School | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Grace Reynolds | Martinsville High School | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Allie Shondell | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Avery Ross- | Pendleton Heights High School | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Janet Moala | Penn High School | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Ava Utterback | Plainfield High School | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Olivia Murphy | Roncalli High School | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Sarah Lezon | Roncalli High School | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Olivia Fish | Seymour High School | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| Courtney Jones | Terre Haute South Vigo | 4A | 2021 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Abigail Cresse | F.W. Blackhawk Christian HS | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Allie Boyer | F.W. Blackhawk Christian HS | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Emiline Wood | F.W. Blackhawk Christian HS | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Regan Wilson | Indpls Lutheran High School | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Kyleigh Courter | Loogootee High School | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Lexi Cripe | South Newton High School | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Taylor Cripe | South Newton High School | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Grace Margaret Drake | Southwood High School | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Bella Nottger | Springs Valley High School | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Brianna Marx | Tecumseh High School | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Jenna Donohoo | Tecumseh High School | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Payge Johnson | Tecumseh High School | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Addison Darlage | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Bailey Tabeling | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2022 | First Team |
| Brianna Bucher | Bloomfield High School | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Abby Reed | Dalesville High School | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Amarah Mcphaul | Dalesville High School | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Delaney Kintz | F.W. Blackhawk Christian HS | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Olivia Martinez | F.W. Blackhawk Christian HS | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Emma Segal | Frontier High School | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Cathryn Erwin | Indpls Lutheran High School | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Hadleigh Filipovich | Indpls Lutheran High School | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Sydnee Wittmer | Loogootee High School | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Allie Hacker | Southwood High School | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Leigh Carnres | Springs Valley High School | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Ava Kissel | Tecumseh High School | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Laura Roeder | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Mary Herman | Vincennes Rivet High School | 1A | 2022 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Annelise Allegretti | Andrean High School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Audrey Nohos | Andrean High School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Kara Schutz | Andrean High School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Marin Sanchez | Andrean High School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Grace Roach | Lafayette Central Catholic High School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Kaitlyn Kuckkan | Lafayette Central Catholic High School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Alexis Baney | Madison-Grant High School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Daya Greene | Madison-Grant High School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Ava Smith | Park Tudor School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Abigail McCoy | Scecina Memorial School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Cora Baker | South Adams High School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Camryn Wise | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Chloe Cook | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2022 | First Team |
| Macie Bowden | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Sophie Wischmeier | Brownstown Central High School | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Sydney Swan | Clinton Prairie Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Avery Martin | Illiana Christian | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Rachel Vorst | Lafayette Central Catholic High School | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Lauren Paska | Lapel Sr High School | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Lilly Claire Howell | Muncie Burris Laboratory School | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Mandee Weisenburger | Pioneer Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Mackenzie Rogers | Pioneer Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Alexandra Kouskousakis | Rochester Community High Sch | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Allison Daves | Scecina Memorial School | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Macy Pries | South Adams High School | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Reese Baker | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Ella Mauck | Wes-Del MiddleSenior High School | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Caitlyn Campbell | Winchester Community High School | 2A | 2022 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Morgann Gaerte | Angola High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Delaney Lawson | Bellmont High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Lauren Ross | Bellmont High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Sami Christen | Bellmont High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Josie Nobbe | Greensburg High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Kate Zellers | Heritage Jr/Sr. High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Macy Lengacher | NorthWood High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Grace Purichia | Providence High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Makenzie Wagner | Providence High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Lilly Tappel | Providence High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Addison Makun | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Elle Patterson | Tri-West High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Reagan Durbin | Western Boone High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Elena Gubera | Western Boone High School | 3A | 2022 | First Team |
| Mya Ball | Angola High School | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Dylan DeCoursey | Barr Reeve High School | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Hailey Cole | Bellmont High School | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Sienna Foster | Benton Central High School | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Macy Bruton | Crawfordsville High School | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Audrey Hudson | FW Bishop Dwenger | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Jersey Loyer | FW Concordia Lutheran | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Ella Chapman | Greensburg High School | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Claire Castor | Guerin Catholic High School | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Claire Bickel | Heritage Jr/Sr. High School | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Madison McCubbins | Monrovia High School | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Keira Lucas | Northview High School | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Lilly Kaiser | Providence High School | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Ellie Priddy | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2022 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Lola Schumacher | Brebeuf High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Quinci Thomas | Brownsburg High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Caroline Hilbrich | Floyd Central High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Mandy Hess | Floyd Central High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Ava Vickers | Fishers High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Avery Hobson | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Lauren Harden | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Macy Hinshaw | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Chloe Chicoine | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Reagan Burns | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Aly Kirkhoff | Roncalli High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Charlotte Vinson | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Emilee Hill | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Addi Applegate | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2022 | First Team |
| Sydney Robinson | Brebeuf High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Lauren Evans | Carmel High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Brenna Ginder | Carroll High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Breanna Lane | Castle High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Gabby Dean | Columbus East High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Vanessa Del Real | Crown Point High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Sophie Ledbetter | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Addison Tindall | Homestead High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Molly Urban | Martinsville High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Allie Shondell | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Macy Hatkevich | Penn High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Olivia Fish | Seymour High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Kennedy Wagner | Valparaiso High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| Avery Hales | Warsaw High School | 4A | 2022 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Abbie Cresse | F.W. Blackhawk Christian Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Allie Boyer | F.W. Blackhawk Christian Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Emma Segal | Frontier Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Cathryn Erwin | Indpls. Lutheran High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Taylor Cripe | South Newton Senior High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Grace Drake | Southwood Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Allie Haecker | Southwood Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Shania Rhamy | Southwood Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Leigh Carnes | Springs Valley Comm High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Jenna Donohoo | Tecumseh Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Payge Johnson | Tecumseh Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Addison Darlage | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Laura Roeder | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Anna Herman | Vincennes Rivet High School | 1A | 2023 | First Team |
| Shaye Watson | Elkhart Christian Academy | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Aesha Vogt | Faith Christian Academy | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Olivia Martinez | F.W. Blackhawk Christian | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Delaney Kintz | F.W. Blackhawk Christian | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Hadleigh Filipovich | Indpls. Lutheran High School | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Emma Poitras | Kouts High School | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Sydnee Wittmer | Loogootee High School | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Madison Ramsey | Loogootee High School | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Bryn VanVleet | Seton Catholic High School | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Maddie Carnes | Springs Valley High School | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Ava Kissel | Tecumseh Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Emily Hall | Tecumseh Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Sara Zarse | Tri-County High school | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Carso Bowling | Trinity Luthern High School | 1A | 2023 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Marin Sanchez | Andrean High School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Sophie Wischmeier | Brownstown Central High School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Ella Boersema | Churubusco Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Kaitlyn Kuckkan | Lafayette Central Catholic High School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Rachel Vorst | Lafayette Central Catholic High School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Lauren Paska | Lapel Sr High School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Ella Warrick | Linton-Stockton High School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Audrey Warrick | Linton-Stockton High School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Lillly Howell | Muncie Burris Laboratory School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Layla Gonzales. | Muncie Burris Laboratory School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Addie Fullop | North Posey Sr High School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Isabelle Martinelle | Scecina Memorial School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Tatum Wade | South Central Union Mills High School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Ella Mauck | Wes-Del MiddleSenior High School | 2A | 2023 | First Team |
| Jaydynn Yeadon | Brownstown Central High School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Jenna Odle | Eastern Greentown High School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Becca Robbins | Linton-Stockton High School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Sophie Hale | Linton-Stockton High School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Aubrey Miller | Muncie Burris Laboratory School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Ashton Elpers | North Posey Sr High School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Brooklyn Borges | Pioneer Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Mackenzie-Ruth Rogers | Pioneer Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Natalie Bollenbacher | Scecina Memorial School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Chase Lemming | Seeger Memorial Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Macy Pries | South Adams High School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Hope Welsh | South Central Union Mills High School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Lauren Rich | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Rachel McGlothin | Wes-Del MiddleSenior High School | 2A | 2023 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Morgan Gaerte | Angola High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Mya Ball | Angola High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Delaney Lawson | Bellmont Senior High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Hailey Cole | Bellmont Senior High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Sami Christen | Bellmont Senior High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Calista Foster | Benton Central Jr-Sr High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Avery Parris | Evansville Reitz Memorial High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Jersey Loyer | F.W. Concordia Lutheran High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Kennedy Cherry | Hamilton Heights High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Lilly Tappel | Providence High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Makenzie Wagner | Providence High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Addison Makun | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Isabelle Masten | Tri-West Senior High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Raegan Durbin | Western Boone Jr-Sr High School | 3A | 2023 | First Team |
| Addison Jones | Barr Reeve Jr-Sr High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Hannah Bledsoe | Barr Reeve Jr-Sr High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| MaryKate Scheumann | Bellmont Senior High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Sienna Foster | Benton Central Jr-Sr High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Reegan Buck | Evansville Reitz Memorial High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Jillian Tippmann | F.W. Bishop Dwenger High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Keira Jade Lucas | Northview High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Claire Payne | NorthWood High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Camila Adams | Providence High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Ellie Priddy | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| AVA Kopf | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Caroline Ward | Tri-West Senior High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Kate Eastman | Tri-West Senior High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Alayna Christner | Western Boone Jr-Sr High School | 3A | 2023 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Lola Schumacher | Brebeuf Jesuit Prep | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Addisen Gallentine | Castle High School | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Katie Kopshever | Castle High School | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Lauren Harden | Hamilton Southeastern HS | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Lindsey Mangelson | Hamilton Southeastern HS | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Macy Hinshaw | Hamilton Southeastern HS | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Sophie Ledbetter | Hamilton Southeastern HS | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Addison Tindall | Homestead High School | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Allie Shondell | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Ava Utterback | Plainfield High School | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Aly Kirkhoff | Roncalli High School | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Logan Bell | Roncalli High School | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Addie Applegate | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Charlotte Vinson | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2023 | First Team |
| Isabelle Brown | Avon High School | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Brenna Ginder | Carroll High School | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Kamryn Utley | Cathedral High School | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Taylor Lewis | Cathedral High School | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Reese Dunkle | Center Grove High School | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Lucy Kay | Fishers High School | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Carly Fonda | Flyod Central High School | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Breonna Goss | Hamilton Southeastern HS | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Tiffany Snook | Hamilton Southeastern HS | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Ava Holtz | LaPorte High School | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Bella Meier | LaPorte High School | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Leah Richmond | Lawrence North High School | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Alaleh Tolliver | North Central High School | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| Isabelle Poehlein | Zionsville High School | 4A | 2023 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Avery Kerr | Christian Academy of Indiana | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Anna Riley | Faith Christian | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Molly Miller | Faith Christian | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Olivia Barber | Faith Christian | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Adele Evans | Indpls. Lutheran High School | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Cathryn Erwin | Indpls. Lutheran High School | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Kaitlyn Kuckkan | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Taylor Cripe | South Newton Senior High School | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Maddie Carnes | Springs Valley Comm High School | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Sara Zarse | Tri-County Middle-Senior High | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Addison Darlage | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Carson Bowling | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Laura Roeder | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Madison Keith | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2024 | First Team |
| Abbey Swan | Clinton Prairie Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Alexandra Sutherlin | Covington Community High School | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Brynn Berndt | Culver Community High School | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Zoe Sondag | Indpls. Lutheran High School | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Carley Barrett | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Grace Bordenet | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Keirsten Vivian Nies | Pioneer Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Bryn VanVleet | Seton Catholic High School | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Brylee Faulk | Shakamak Jr-Sr High School | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Kinsey Saliba | Springs Valley Comm High School | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Grace Luck | Tri-County Middle-Senior High | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Hannah Arvin | Tri-County Middle-Senior High | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Bailey Bonde | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Rachel Bonde | Trinity Lutheran High School | 1A | 2024 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Addison Nicole Jones | Barr Reeve Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2024 | First Team |
| Hannah Bledsoe | Barr Reeve Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2024 | First Team |
| Calista Foster | Benton Central Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2024 | First Team |
| Jaydynn Yeadon | Brownstown Central High School | 2A | 2024 | First Team |
| Kinzee Dean | Brownstown Central High School | 2A | 2024 | First Team |
| Sophie Wischmeier | Brownstown Central High School | 2A | 2024 | First Team |
| Ella Warrick | Linton-Stockton High School | 2A | 2024 | First Team |
| Lilly Howell | Muncie Burris Laboratory School | 2A | 2024 | First Team |
| Molly Welborn | Scecina Memorial School | 2A | 2024 | First Team |
| Grace Drake | Southwood Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2024 | First Team |
| Shania Rhamy | Southwood Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2024 | First Team |
| Sophia Beeson | Wapahani High School | 2A | 2024 | First Team |
| Raegan Durbin | Western Boone Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2024 | First Team |
| Sadie Poeck | Western Boone Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2025 | First Team |
| Mati Henry | Adams Central High School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Lanie Marie Graber | Barr Reeve Jr-Sr High School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Finley Wheeler | Brownstown Central High School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Kenzie Mann | Covenant Christian High School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Maelee Pilant | Linton-Stockton High School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Becca Robbins | Linton-Stockton High School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Isabelle Martinelle | Scecina Memorial School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Ava Kissel | Tecumseh High School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Katelyn Marx | Tecumseh High School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Reagan Bollenbacher | South Adams High School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Jacie Wilson | Sullivan High School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Lyndi Whitenack | Winchester Community High School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Auden Hummel | Winchester Community High School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Lilyana Mayberry | Winchester Community High School | 2A | 2024 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Maya Harris | Angola High School | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Sophia Nowacki | Hammond Bishop Noll Institute | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Bradee Ann McDonald | Northview High School | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Keira Jade Lucas | Northview High School | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Claire Payne | NorthWood High School | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Sophia Barber | NorthWood High School | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Addie Haberthy | Roncalli High School | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Logan Bell | Roncalli High School | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Lydia Stahley | Roncalli High School | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Mac Kruer | Roncalli High School | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Reagan Turk | Roncalli High School | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Addison Makun | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Brooklynn Renn | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Izzy Masten | Tri-West Senior High School | 3A | 2024 | First Team |
| Ava Harris | Angola High School | 3A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Avery Lewis | Cathedral High School | 3A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Caroline Hanchar | Cathedral High School | 3A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Addie Phillippe | Delta High School | 3A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Zariah Winton | Hammond Bishop Noll Institute | 3A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Lauren Wilson | New Castle Chrysler High School | 3A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Azure Flagle | New Palestine High School | 3A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Chloe Deckard | New Prairie High School | 3A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Emily Uhlmann | NorthWood High School | 3A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Eva Hurrle | Roncalli High School | 3A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Haiden Means | Scottsburg Senior High School | 3A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Ava Kopf | Silver Creek High School | 3A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Caroline Ward | Tri West High School | 3A | 2024 | Second Team |
| | | | |
| Isabelle Brown | Avon High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| Delaney Steers | Brownsburg High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| Bailey Sinish | Carroll FW High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| Reese Dunkle | Center Grove High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| Ellen Zapp | Center Grove High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| Ella Schara | Crown Point High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| Carly Fonda | Floyd Central High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| Lindsey Mangelson | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| Ava Hunter | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| Madison Miles | Hamilton Southeastern High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| Addison Tindall | Homestead High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| Charlotte Vinson | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| Addi Applegate | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| Elianna Strecker | Zionsville High School | 4A | 2024 | First Team |
| MaryKate Scheumann | Bellmont High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Avery Freeman | Bloomington North High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Sophia Gisslen | Carroll FW High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Maya Joska | Castle High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Addisen Gallentine | Castle High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Bella Del Real | Crown Point High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Nora Gibson | Floyd Central High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Madelyn Sipe | Homestead High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Lexi Shondell | McCutcheon High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Sarah Noto | Penn High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Abby Juluis | Providence High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Ellie Hepler | Warsaw High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Carsyn Comer | Westfield High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| Shanese Williams | Yorktown High School | 4A | 2024 | Second Team |
| | | | |