| First Name | Last Name | School | Honor |
| 2006 | | | |
| Emily | Burke | Cathedral High School | First Team |
| Kim | Kuzma | Muncie Central High School | First Team |
| Caitlyn | Vann | Muncie Burris High School | First Team |
| | | |
| 2008 | | | |
| Darcy | Dorton | Delta High School | First Team |
| Christiana | Gray | Cathedral High School | First Team |
| Mary | Ording | Cathedral High School | Second Team |
| Mia | Tabberson | Muncie Burris High School | Second Team |
| | | |
| 2009 | | | |
| Taylor | Unroe | Muncie Burris High School | First Team |
| Baily | Barker | Yorktown High School | Honorable Mention |
| Emily | MacIntyre | Yorktown High School | Honorable Mention |
| Melanie | Stutsman | Floyd Central High Scnool | Honorable Mention |
| | | |
| 2010 | | | |
| Lexie | Pawlik | Penn High School | Second Team |
| | | |
| 2011 | | | |
| Annie | Drews | Penn High School | First Team |
| Taylor | Morey | Muncie Burris High School | First Team |
| Madeline | Mayers | Bishop Dwenger High School | Second Team |
| Morgan | Bergren | Delta High School | Second Team |
| Kate | Workman | Valparaiso High School | Second Team |
| | | |
| 2012 | | | |
| Taylor | Lebo | LaPorte High School | Second Team |
| Lauren | Pitz | Carmel High School | Second Team |
| Jazzmine | McDonald | Cathedral High School | Honorable Mention |
| | | |
| 2013 | | | |
| Lauryn | Gillis | New Castle High School | First Team |
| Danielle | Cuttino | Ben Davis High School | Second Team |
| Azariah | Stahl | Elkhart Central High School | Second Team |
| | | |
| 2014 | | | |
| Carly | Skjodt | Carmel High School | First Team |
| Tionna | Williams | Concordia Lutheran High School | First Team |
| Beth | Prince | Avon High School | Second Team |
| Rebecca | Nunge | Castle High School | Third Team |
| Brooke | Peters | Avon High School | Third Team |
| Remi | Bowman | Floyd Central High School | Honorable Mention |
| Shavona | Cuttino | Ben Davis High School | Honorable Mention |
| Bailey | Schnell | Roncalli High School | Honorable Mention |
| Tarah | Wylie | Cathedral High School | Honorable Mention |
| | | |
| 2015 | | | |
| Kendall | White | Cathedral High School | Second Team |
| Jaqueline | Quade | Carroll High School | Third Team |
| Hayden | Huybers | Hamilton Southeastern HS | Honorable Mention |
| Megan | Sloan | Cathedral High School | Honorable Mention |
| Madison | Smeathers | Center Grove High School | Honorable Mention |
| | | |
| 2016 | | | |
| Nia | Robinson | Cathedral High School | Second Team |
| Bayli | Lebo | LaPorte High School | Honorable Mention |
| Monroe | Olsen | Valparaiso High School | Honorable Mention |
| Maria | Schorr | Cathedral High School | Honorable Mention |
| | | |
| 2017 | | | |
| Marissa | Hornung | Providence High School | First Team |
| Darian | Goins | Avon High School | Second Tea |
| Morgan | Chacon | Crown Point High School | Third Team |
| Allyson | Cathey | New Albany High School | Honorable Mention |
| Katie | Isenbarger | Zionsville High School | Honorable Mention |
| Jael | Johnson | Avon High School | Honorable Mention |
| Megan | Miller | Alexandria-Monroe High School | Honorable Mention |
| | | |
| 2018 | | | |
| Caitie | Baird | Perry Meridian High School | First Team |
| Madison | Horin | Munster High School | First Team |
| Makenzie | Knuckles | Yorktown High School | First Team |
| Rose | Duffy | Fishers High School | Honorable Mention |
| Jessica | Nunge | Castle High School | Honorable Mention |
| Brooke | Phillips | Franklin Community High School | Honorable Mention |
| Ava | Torrance | Avon High School | Honorable Mention |
| | | |
| 2019 | | | |
| Melani | Shaffmaster | New Castle High School | First Team |
| Madison (MJ) | Hammill | Center Grove High School | Second Team |
| Savana | Chacon | Crown Point High School | Third Team |
| Brooke | Humphrey | McCutcheon High School | Honorable Mention |
| Brooke | Smith | Leo High School | Honorable Mention |
| | | |
| 2020 | | | |
| Ali | Hornung | Providence High School | First Team |
| Mabrey | Shaffmaster | New Castle High School | Second Team |
| Ellee | Stinson | Yorktown High School | Second Team |
| Carly | Mills | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Third Team |
| Raven | Colvin | Heritage Christian School | Honorable Mention |
| Abby | Maesch | Avon High School | Honorable Mention |
| Lourdes | Torres | Munster High School | Honorable Mention |
| | | |
| 2021 | | | |
| Emma | Halter | Roncalli High School | First Team |
| Grace | Reynolds | Martinsville High School | First Team |
| Emma | Hickey | Penn High School | Second Team |
| Cecilia | Bulmahn | Mt. Vernon High School | Third Team |
| Aniya | Kennedy | LaPorte High School | Honorable Mention |
| Kendall | Meller | Brownsburg High School | Honorable Mention |
| Janet | Moala | Penn High School | Honorable Mention |
| Keira | Moore | Castle High School | Honorable Mention |
| Olivia | Murphy | Roncalli High School | Honorable Mention |
| Gentry | Warrick | Linton-Stockton School Corporation | Honorable Mention |
| | | |
| 2022 | | | |
| Chloe | Chicoine | McCutcheon High School | First Team |
| Emilee | Hill | Yorktown High School | First Team |
| Raegan | Burns | McCutcheon High School | Second Team |
| Grace | Purichia | Providence High School | Second Team |
| Kennedy | Wagner | Valparaiso High School | Second Team |
| Macy | Bruton | Crawfordsville High School | Honorable Mention |
| Faith | Burch | Roncalli High School | Honorable Mention |
| Lexi | Cripe | South Newton High School | Honorable Mention |
| Gabby | Gilbert | Pike High School | Honorable Mention |
| Avery | Hales | Warsaw High School | Honorable Mention |
| Ella | Scott | Plainfield High School | Honorable Mention |
| Kaylee | Weeks | Warsaw High School | Honorable Mention |
| | | |
| 2023 | | | |
| Mya | Ball | Angola High School | First Team |
| Morgan | Gaerte | Angola High School | First Team |
| Lola | Schumacher | Brebeuf Jesuit High School | First Team |
| Mia | Loyd | Terre Haute South Vigo High School | Second Team |
| Lilly | Merk | Terre Haute South Vigo High School | Third Team |
| Makenzie | Wagner | Providence High School | Third Team |
| Brenna | Ginder | Carroll High School | Honorable Mention |
| Olivia | Gisslen | Carroll High School | Honorable Mention |
| Melaina | Hawblitzel | Warsaw Community High School | Honorable Mention |
| Trinitie | Lintner | Lowell High School | Honorable Mention |
| Madison | Ramsey | Loogootee Jr/Sr High School | Honorable Mention |
| Emma | Segal | Frontier Jr/Sr High School | Honorable Mention |
| Shaye | Watson | Elkhart Christian Academy | Honorable Mention |
| | | |
| 2024 | | | |
| Addison | Tindall | Homestead High School | First Team |
| Addi | Applegate | Yorktown High School | Second Team |
| Logan | Bell | Roncalli High School | Second Team |
| Lindsey | Mangelson | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Second Team |
| | | |
| 2025 | | | |
| Madison | Miles | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Second Team |
| Bailey | Sinish | Carroll High School | Second Team |
| Audrey | Utterback | Plainfield High School | Second Team |
| Maya | Harris | Angola High School | Third Team |
| Elle | Schara | Crown Point High School | Third Team |
| Caroline | Ward | Tri-West High School | Third Team |
| Luca | Bombacino | Chesterton High School | Honorable Mention |
| Bella | Del Real | Crown Point High School | Honorable Mention |
| Maya | Harris | Angola High School | Honorable Mention |
| Ella | Warrick | Linton-Stockton School Corporation | Honorable Mention |