The list of former Indiana Gatorade Players of the Year is impressive. A few have gone to compete for a national championship, earned NCAA All-America honors and continue their playing career at the professional level.
Many are distinguished professionals, exceptional educators/coaches, and great mothers.
Below is the list of Indiana Gatorade Players of the Year honorees
| 1995 | SARA SORRELL | Muncie Central |
| 1996 | CHRISTINE GIRTON | Muncie Central |
| 1997 | ERICA MYERS | Muncie Burris |
| 1998 | KRISTIN FRYE | FW Northrup |
| 1999 | CARA SMITH | Harrison |
| 2000 | ALLYNE REBHOLZ | Cathedral |
| 2001 | AMY MORRIS | Michigan City |
| 2002 | AMANDA MCCORMICK | Muncie Burris |
| 2003 | KATELYN BISHOP | Terre Haute South |
| 2004 | DANITA MERLAU | Cathedral |
| 2005 | SARAH “SAM” GRAY | Brebeuf Jesuit |
| 2006 | PAIGE WEBER | Roncalli |
| 2007 | CAITLIN COX | New Castle |
| 2008 | DARCY DORTON | Delta |
| 2009 | TAYLOR UNROE | Muncie Burris |
| 2010 | TAYLOR MOREY | Muncie Burris |
| 2011 | EMILY WOLFERT | Yorktown |
| 2012 | LAURYN GILLIS | New Castle |
| 2013 | AZARIAH STAHL | Elkhart Cenral |
| 2014 | CARLY SKJODT | Carmel |
| 2015 | KENDALL WHITE | Cathedral |
| 2016 | NIA ROBINSON | Cathedral |
| 2017 | MELANI SHAFFMASTER | New Castle |
| 2018 | KENZIE KNUCKLES | Yorktown |
| 2019 | MELANI SHAFFMASTER | New Castle |
| 2020 | ALI HORNUNG | Providence |