| College | Player | High School | Yr. |
| Bethany (WV) | Asia Crim | Loogootee | So. |
| Bethany (WV) | Andie Clark | Hauser | Fr. |
| Bethany (WV) | Taylor Love | Purdue Polytechnic | Fr. |
| Calvin | Emma Ekblaw | Chesterton | So. |
| Carnegie Mellon | Elizabeth Phillips | Brebeuf Jesuit | Fr. |
| Case Western | Alyssa Blessinger | Evans. Reitz Memorial | Sr. |
| Juniata | Samantha Hanson | Cathedral | Fr. |
| MIT | Ashley Margetts | Brownsburg | Sr. |
| Mount Union | Jaclyn Scherb | Carmel | Jr. |
| Mt. St. Joseph | Mackenzie Rice | Andrean | Fr. |
| Mt. St. Joseph | Ruthie Bingham | Trinity Lutheran | So. |
| North Park | Delaney Lynch | Bloomington South | Sr. |
| North Park | Kyla Wooden | Warren Central | So. |
| North Park | Maicee Sterrett | Frankfort | Fr. |
| Otterbein | Kennedy Hoffman | Trinity Lutheran | Jr. |
| Transylvania | Kayden Holcomb | Floyd Central | Jr. |
| Tufts | Claire Castor | Guerin Catholic | Fr. |
| Washington U | Mallory Dills | Cathedral | Fr. |
| Wis.-Oshkosh | Lexi Cline | Portage | Fr. |